Failed payment recovery tools compared (2026)
Stripe and Square already recover some failed payments on their own. Stripe retries the card with Smart Retries and can email the customer after each failure. When a subscription charge fails on Square, it emails the customer the invoice with a link to pay. A paid recovery tool earns its fee on whatever is still unpaid after that. Here's how Stripe's built-in tools compare with Churnkey, Churn Buster, Stunning, Paddle Retain, and our own product, Recoura, based on each company's own pages as of November 12, 2026.
What happens when a Stripe payment fails
Stripe's Smart Retries automatically retries failed subscription and invoice payments. Stripe turns it on by default for new accounts, with up to 8 retries within 2 weeks, and the Billing pricing page lists Smart Retries as included. Billing itself costs 0.7% of Billing volume on pay as you go. Our Stripe Smart Retries guide covers the settings.
Stripe can also email the customer after each failed payment once you turn on Send emails when card payments fail in its revenue recovery settings. And it automatically attempts to update saved card details when a customer gets a new card, such as a replacement for an expired one, as long as the card's issuer takes part. The setup and the limits of those emails are in our guide to Stripe's failed payment emails.
That leaves two gaps. When a payment returns a hard decline code, Stripe's docs say the issuing bank has rejected the transaction, and Stripe can't retry it without a new payment method. And since Stripe's emails follow failed payment attempts, they end when the retries do. Our guide to Stripe decline codes explains which declines are hard. The tools below aim at these two gaps.
The tools side by side
Everything in these tables comes from each vendor's own pages, read on November 12, 2026. We left out vendor-reported recovery rates, because we can't check them.
What each tool does
| Tool | Retries the card | Contacts the customer |
|---|---|---|
| Stripe's built-in tools | Yes, with Smart Retries | An email after each failed payment, if you turn it on |
| Churnkey | Yes, on top of Stripe's own retries | SMS, email, or in your app |
| Churn Buster | Yes | Email, then SMS, then an alert to your team |
| Stunning | Keeps Stripe's retries on, and can charge a backup card | Up to 8 emails you write, SMS, and an in-app notice |
| Paddle Retain | Yes | Up to 4 recovery emails and 1 SMS |
| Recoura | No, it leaves retries to the processor | Emails you can edit, with a link to pay, plus an optional in-app banner on Stripe |
Billing platforms and price
| Tool | Billing platforms it lists | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Stripe's built-in tools | Stripe | Included with Stripe Billing, which charges 0.7% of Billing volume on pay as you go |
| Churnkey | Stripe, Chargebee, Maxio, Paddle, Braintree, plus a custom integration framework | From $250 a month billed yearly, for less than $5k a month in churn volume |
| Churn Buster | Stripe, Braintree, Chargebee, Recharge, and others in its docs, or through its API | From $269 a month for recovery or cancellation flows alone, $430 for both, set by your MRR |
| Stunning | Stripe, with fewer features on Foxy and Subbly | A flat monthly fee set by your MRR: $60 a month at $8k MRR on its price slider |
| Paddle Retain | Stripe, Braintree, Recharge, Maxio, Zuora, and Paddle Billing, in its help center | Included with Paddle Billing, which charges 5% + 50¢ per transaction. Its help center gives a flat fee from $500 a month for smaller companies and performance-based pricing for larger ones |
| Recoura | Stripe, Square | From $39 a month. The Dashboard plan, which shows revenue at risk, is free |
The prices rest on different numbers: Stripe and Paddle Billing charge on what you bill, Churnkey on your monthly churn volume, Churn Buster and Stunning on your MRR, and Recoura by plan. Work out each one for your own business before comparing them.
The tools one by one
Churnkey
Churnkey sells cancellation flows and payment recovery. Its Payment Recovery product covers smart retries, follow-up campaigns, and in-app card updates, and Churnkey says its Precision Retries layer directly on top of Stripe's own retry logic. When a hard decline happens, it reaches customers by SMS, email, or in your app.
- Good fit: Stripe, Chargebee, Maxio, Paddle, or Braintree businesses that also want fewer voluntary cancellations. The Starter plan includes both Cancel Flows and Payment Recovery.
- Worth knowing: Starter costs $250 a month billed yearly and is for teams with less than $5k a month in churn volume. Square isn't among the payment providers Churnkey lists, though it offers a custom integration framework for others.
Churn Buster
Churn Buster sells failed payment recovery and cancellation flows, together or separately. Its recovery emails go out from a dedicated pool on your domain, followed by SMS and then an alert to your team, and it uses a retry strategy tuned to recency, frequency, and duration. On Stripe and Braintree it adds a no-login card update page with 3D Secure.
- Good fit: Teams that want a vendor's help tuning recovery. Its plans include guidance from its retention team and run month to month with no contract.
- Worth knowing: Its pricing page says your MRR sets a flat monthly fee, from $269 a month for one product and $430 for both, and setup takes about an hour with its team. Its docs name Square once, in a list of other integrations, with no Square setup guide.
Stunning
Stunning works alongside Stripe. You keep Stripe's retries on and turn off Stripe's failed payment and expiring card emails, and Stunning sends up to eight emails that you write, each more urgent than the last, plus SMS and an in-app notice. It tries to update an expiring card automatically, can charge a customer's backup card, and also supports Foxy and Subbly with a smaller feature set. Its Managed Recovery service has Stunning's team run recovery for you.
- Good fit: Stripe businesses that want more channels than email, or want someone else to run recovery.
- Worth knowing: Stunning says you pay a flat monthly fee based on your MRR and that it never takes a percentage of what it recovers. SMS, backup cards, and Stunning-hosted payment pages work on Stripe only.
Paddle Retain
Paddle Retain handles failed payments and cancellations, and Paddle calls it "Paddle Billing's built-in retention toolkit". Its help center describes up to four recovery emails, the first 2 hours after a payment fails, and one SMS between the first and second emails. Customers update their card on a form that needs no sign-in, and Apple Pay and Google Pay can be added. Paddle documents Retain's retry schedule for Paddle Billing, with up to 7 retries over about 20 days, and its product page says Retain works with your billing system's smart retries. Retain's setup guides cover Stripe, Braintree, Recharge, Maxio, and Paddle Billing.
- Good fit: Businesses on Paddle Billing, where Retain comes at no extra cost, or teams that want failed payment recovery, cancellation flows, and annual-plan upgrade offers in one tool.
- Worth knowing: Paddle's help center says Retain's pricing is "performance-based for larger companies and flat-fee for smaller ones (starting at $500/month)". It recommends a grace period of 21 days and says Retain needs at least 10 days to work.
Recoura
Recoura connects to Stripe or Square and doesn't retry cards. When a payment is still unpaid, it checks your live processor data and emails the customer, in your business's name, a link to pay on Stripe's or Square's hosted invoice page. You set the reminder schedule and the email's wording, or send a reminder by hand. On Stripe, you can also add a banner to your app that shows a customer what they owe, with a button to pay and update their card. For soft declines on Stripe, it steps in only after Smart Retries has finished, and on Square it waits out a grace period after the invoice falls overdue.
- Good fit: Businesses on Square, or on Stripe, that want follow-up emails checked against live processor data before they go out, from $39 a month.
- Worth knowing: Recoura doesn't retry cards, so on Stripe it runs alongside Stripe's retries. Plans start at $39 a month, and the free Dashboard plan shows your revenue at risk. The main pricing page has the current plans.
Failed payment recovery on Square
Square merchants have fewer choices here. Of the tools compared, Recoura is the one whose own pages list Square. Churnkey lists Stripe, Chargebee, Maxio, Paddle, and Braintree, Stunning lists Stripe, Foxy, and Subbly, and Paddle Retain's setup guides cover Stripe, Braintree, Recharge, Maxio, and Paddle Billing. Churn Buster's docs name Square once, with no setup guide. Tools we haven't compared may support Square, so ask the vendor before you rule one out.
Square handles part of the job itself. Its subscription billing documentation says that when a subscription has a card on file and Square's attempt to charge it fails, Square sends the invoice to the customer's email address with a link for making a payment. Its invoices troubleshooting page adds that when a card is declined, Square is not informed of the exact reason. Our guides to Square decline codes and Square Invoices go further into both.
On Square, Recoura works from the unpaid invoice. Once the invoice is overdue and the grace period has passed, it checks that the invoice is still unpaid and emails the customer a link to pay it.
How to choose a failed payment recovery tool
Check what's left after your processor's own recovery first. If Smart Retries and Stripe's emails already bring back most failed payments, a paid tool may not pay for itself. If a meaningful amount stays unpaid, match the gap to the tool:
| If you want | Look at |
|---|---|
| To cut cancellations too | Churnkey, Churn Buster, or Paddle Retain, which all sell cancellation flows |
| Someone else to run recovery | Stunning's Managed Recovery, or Churn Buster, whose plans include guidance from its retention team |
| SMS as well as email | Churnkey, Churn Buster, Stunning on Stripe, or Paddle Retain |
| Recovery included in your billing platform | Stripe's own tools, or Paddle Retain on Paddle Billing |
| Square support, or follow-up emails checked against live processor data | Recoura |
| To handle it yourself | Stripe's failed payment emails, plus your own follow-up from the templates in our guide |
Questions to ask any vendor
- Does it retry the card, send the customer a link, or both?
- Who sends the emails, and from what domain?
- What happens after a hard decline, when retrying won't help?
- How is the price set, and what happens to it as you grow?
- How does it avoid contacting a customer who has already paid?
A rough test for any of them: if the monthly price is lower than the revenue it would plausibly bring back, it's worth a trial. Our guide to what failed payments are costing you helps you estimate what's at stake.
Failed payment recovery tools FAQ
Which failed payment recovery tools work with Square?
Of the tools compared here, Recoura is the one whose own pages list Square. Churn Buster's docs name Square once, with no setup guide, and Churnkey, Stunning, and Paddle Retain don't list it. Tools we haven't compared may support Square, so ask the vendor before you rule one out.
Which tools retry the card, and which only contact the customer?
Stripe's Smart Retries, Churnkey, Churn Buster, and Paddle Retain retry the card. Stunning keeps Stripe's retries on and can charge a customer's backup card. Recoura doesn't retry cards. It emails the customer a link to pay, and for soft declines on Stripe it steps in only after Smart Retries has finished.
Is Stripe Smart Retries enough on its own?
It can be. Stripe retries failed payments, can email the customer after each one, and lists Smart Retries as included in Billing. It can't retry a payment that returns a hard decline code without a new payment method, though, and its emails stop when its retries do. If a meaningful amount stays unpaid after that, the other tools here are built for that gap.
Is there failed payment recovery without a monthly fee?
Yes, when it comes with your billing platform. Stripe Billing includes Smart Retries and charges 0.7% of Billing volume on pay as you go. Paddle includes Retain at no extra cost in Paddle Billing, which charges 5% + 50¢ per transaction. Churnkey, Churn Buster, and Stunning charge a monthly fee for recovery, and Recoura's recovery plans start at $39 a month, with a free Dashboard plan that shows your revenue at risk.
Do any of these tools take a percentage of what they recover?
Paddle says Retain's pricing is performance-based for larger companies, and the pages we read don't give the terms. Stunning says it never takes a percentage of what it recovers, Churn Buster lists no commissions, Churnkey prices by your monthly churn volume, and Recoura charges a flat monthly price per plan. Outside this comparison, Butter Payments says it takes a small percentage of the revenue from each invoice it recovers, and FlyCode says it charges only for revenue it recovers above your baseline.
Can I use a recovery tool alongside Stripe's retries?
Yes, and most are built for it. Churnkey says its Precision Retries layer on top of Stripe's own retry logic, Stunning keeps Stripe's retries on and takes over the customer emails, and Paddle says Retain works with your billing system's smart retries. For soft declines, Recoura steps in only after Smart Retries has finished. Stunning recommends turning off Stripe's failed payment emails so customers only hear from Stunning.
Sources and what we left out
We read all of these pages on November 12, 2026. The comparison rests on the vendors' public pages and documentation, not hands-on testing. Prices and features change, so check the linked pages before you decide.
- Stripe: Smart Retries documentation, customer emails documentation, automatic card updates, and the Billing pricing page
- Churnkey: home page and pricing page
- Churn Buster: home page, pricing page, and other integrations docs
- Stunning: home page, which includes its pricing
- Paddle: Retain page, failed payment recovery page, pricing page, and help center articles on Retain's cost, its retry schedule, its emails, SMS, and setup
- Butter Payments and FlyCode, for the pricing answer in the FAQ: Butter's pricing page and FlyCode's pricing page
- Square: subscription billing documentation and invoices troubleshooting page
We left out tools whose own pages we couldn't read, and tools whose pages disagreed about Square support. If anything here is out of date, email support@recoura.io and we'll fix it.
Square is a trademark of Block, Inc. Recoura is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Square or Block, Inc.
Back to all articles